"High Definition" bullshit. Is Apple our savior?

Posted by Nick

 

Retinadisplay

There are some peak levels of bullshit happening in the computer industry right now. I recently flipped open my new Dell mailer and checked out the laptop selection. I was happily surprised to see the power and price of these systems continue to drop. But it would seem, so does the resolution of their screens. Now all the laptops are marked "HD" (1366 x 768px) or "HD+" (1600x900)...even for their 17.3" monster laptops. HD my ass.

Hdtv
Let me shed some light on why this is epic bullshit. In 2004 I purchased a Dell laptop with a 17" monitor and a resolution of 1920x1200px, that's more than "Full HD" in marketing terms (aka "1080p" or 1920x1080px). This make no sense. Why are resolutions decreasing? The only explanation that I can figure is because most consumers could care less what these numbers actually mean and these computer companies exploit it. They can sell lower resolution (and cheaper) screens to consumers and label them "HD+", which sounds WAY cooler than a set of big numbers.

This is possibly one area Apple can save us poor, ill informed comsumers? If you know me, this is a strange question to come from my mouth...err fingers. With the iPhone4 and it's (lovely marketed) "Retina Display", it features a resolution of 960x640 pixels... which is fewer than the laptops above, but when you consider all these little pixels are being jammed into a tiny 3.5" screen, you end up with a brilliantly crisp image. My hope is that because of Apple's powerful marketing machine and the consumers getting used to higher resolutions, they can collectively pressure other hardware manufactures into bumping their resolutions as well. This isn't just a numbers battle, with higher resolutions on smaller screens we can fit far more information at once and still make it legible.

For once in my life I'm uttering the words "Go Apple!". Even though I still greatly prefer my Evo 4G with it's "lowly" 800x480 screen. ;)

Evo 4G Review - Part 2: Sprint & 4G

Posted by Nick

 

Evocrushiphone_1

(Picture of my first iPhone after it's disastrous fight with my Evo. (aka it fell from several feet)) 


Continued today is my coverage of the Evo 4G. Previously I covered the hardware and now it's time to talk about Sprint's network that carries my data bits to and fro, including 4G.

Sprint

In about 2003, I switched to Cingular from Nextel (who is ironically now Sprint). I made this switch for the greater selection of new phones and the ability to import foreign phones which are far more advanced. I did this for several years, basking in the glory of having too-good-for-the-US hardware in my hand. 

Then the iPhone came out. It changed the world of cell phones and mobile computing. After many long discussions with my close friend, we came to the conclusion that the iPhone was the best phone you could buy. So I used that for 2 years, and during this time I personally found that our conclusion was horribly wrong.

The iPhone is a great piece of technology, a mini-computer that raised the bar for Human-Computer interactions for all devices, changed the world's perspective on what a smartphone is. Yet ultimately, it's a terrible phone. Whether this is AT&Ts or Apple's fault, I don't care...when I had that phone, in this city, I could hardly ever make a call from my house, at work, and on the train. When it did connect, I swear to whatever god it dropped my calls at least 50% of the time.

Three weeks in, the Evo on Sprint's network continues to surprise me. Every time I hit the "Call" button, the phone instantly responds with a slight buzz indicating the call is connected and ringing...what a novelty! On top of that, I get signal everywhere I've been and I've yet to wait for network bars to fill up to make a call. Sprint's 3G network in Chicago is great and I'm taking full advantage of it.

However, I am slightly worried about rural coverage. I've heard reports that Sprint may be very solid in urban areas but once you leave them, the name of the game is Roaming. In late July, I'll be taking a trip to the middle-of-nowhere Michigan, and I'll get my first real chance to test this out. 

As for the Chicago suburbs, 3G held strong. I took an hour-long drive out there this past weekend, from my garage in the city to the Grayslake area, a route that I was used to experience frequent signal drops. But feeling confident with Sprint, I fired up Pandora, plugged the Evo into the AUX jack of my other favorite possession:

Trackday_-_mazdaspeed3

In the two hours of driving, I felt like I was in the future. I bypassed the archaic FM tuner and instead floated digital bits of music to my phone, through my car, and into my ears, uninterrupted, for the entire trip to and fro. I know Pandora streaming over cell networks has been around for a while...but for some reason this felt totally new and exciting. With this new found confidence and reassurance of the music not cutting out, I find myself using this setup more and more. It's awesome.
 

4G

4g_headline2

Sprint_4g_wimax_htc_evo_4g_map

Here in Chicago, we're one of the lucky cities to be blanketed in succulent 4G coverage. As one of my friends put it, it's like having a "mobile land line" to the interwebs, just like being plugged in at home. It's that fast. Game changing fast. When I load a website, the mobile version pops in like it was stored on the phone. I'll try to hunt down the button to load the full version site and in the matter of 3-4 seconds the entire site is loaded. Each map tile loads almost instantly and makes scrolling around to find a route a pleasant experience. "Sexy..." as another friend put it while browsing satellite imagery of Chicago. For those who care, average speeds are 2 to 3.5 mb/s down and 1mb up (which is capped by Sprint), with response times around 50-100ms.

Battery life while using 4G takes a hit. So I toggle it on only when needed, which takes about 10-15 seconds for the Evo to connect to the fat data pipe and away I go.

As for obtaining and maintaining a 4G signal, it's hit or miss. When I do need it, I can connect about 75% of the time. Not having 4G a quarter of the time kinda sucks... kinda. I still always have 3G, which works in a pinch. I think it comes down to perception. If in 2 years from now, when other 4G networks are out there and running strong, and I still can only connect 75% of the time, I'll be pissed. But for now, it's a luxury and one that I'm happy to enjoy when I can get it.

Even if you're not in a 4G zone, Sprint says they'll be covering significantly more parts of the US by the year's end. Specifically, New York, LA, and San Fran will have it by the end of this Summer (2010).

 

Next up, the 3rd and final chapter: Software.

 

Evo 4G Review - Part 1: Hardware

Posted by Nick

 

Evo_seattle

The Evo 4G has been in my hands for 10 days now and I think I've had at least a million conversations about it. Everyone wants to know if it's living up to my hopes and dreams, which you could say were pretty high. Well I'm here to serve:

The review is broken into 4 Parts; Sprint & 4G, Software, and today's topic, Hardware:

Evo_buttons
Screen/Body: A seamless expanse of glass covers the entire face, a rim of red exposes an 8mp camera, and supple "soft touch" texture around back, come together to, well... let's be honest, to look and feel really fucking awesome. I love that this is not a fingerprint magnet. It's meant to be touched, even caressed. The screen, at 800x480, shows off websites in their full glory and displays text exceptionally clear. It may not be "Retina Display" clarity, but I guess I'll survive. ;) When I hit the power button for the first time, the screen's clarity transported me back into the shoes of the first color TV viewers.

Run a fingernail around the edges and the back cover pops off easily, exposing the full red interior of the phone. No practical reason for this - it's there for some subtle (and classy) style. It's got a removable battery (why don't all phones?!) and expandable storage (up to 32gb), all of which are nice and these days a must-have. 

My biggest worry with the hardware is the flat, touch-sensitive buttons for Home, Menu, Back, and Search. I've never liked touch sensitive buttons, always preferring the tactile feedback I get from the <click> of a real switch. But HTC has changed my mind with their perfectly calibrated haptic feedback. It always lets me know the phone has accepted my command with a quick buzz. 

Evoexposed
Battery: Now, the greatest upside to the battery being removable is that, I fear, I'll need to swap it out with a freshly charged one sometimes... this thing eats battery. It being a powerful phone with quite a few radios on board, I was expecting it to be a hog and it's lived up to my expectations. With my iPhone having 2 years of battery degradation, I was getting about 18 hours of moderate use a day. With the brand new Evo... about the same. What this means in the real world: I unplug my Evo at 7:30am, mess around with it bit on the train, make no calls, and by 2pm, I'm usually at about 30% battery. I plug it in for an hour and I'll have plenty of juice to make it till I plug it in before bed at about midnight. I've had days where I use it quite a bit more so I have to plug it in a couple of times. It's only been 10 days, but the battery life has yet to prevent me from doing anything. As long as I don't forget to charge it midday, I'm good. This may be something that would annoy the piss out of you and for you, there are plenty of phones (most I'd guess) that'll do you better. 

Size: Well...it's a bit bigger than I was expecting. I know that a 4.3 inch screen is 0.5 inches larger than my old iPhone, but I had not anticipated its extra width while holding the phone to my ear. It took a couple of days, but now when I pick up my iPhone (living out its retirement years as my bedside Clock/Radio) it feels itty bitty. It's all a matter of perspective. To enjoy a screen that size, the extra weight is well worth it. Zooming happens less on the web and in general, there's far less scrolling through apps, especially while texting. Also the soft keyboard is easier to type on given the larger keys, but I'll talk about that in detail later. 

Evoback8mp
Camera: It films 720p video and takes 8mp snaps and has a flash. Great right? Well it's ok... just like every phone since my first with a camera, it sucks in low light. The LED flash isn't much of a help as it washes everything out within the 5-foot range. Yet, as with every phone since my first with a camera, I've been able to take a few decent snaps here and there. It's all about the right tool for the job. When capturing my little girl in a new outfit to send to her momma, it tends to work out quite well :) As for the video, same story. 720p seems a bit excessive on a phone, but this may be a way to take advantage of the HDMI out the phone features. Oh, it also has a front-facing camera for video calls. More to come on that in the Software section. 
Imag0008

Performance: Being a functional designer, I know the duality, the joy and sadness of doing my job right. The HTC engineers who designed and built this phone did such a great job, I didn't even notice their fantastic work. I had almost forgotten to include this section on performance because I've not once had to think about how fast the Evo is. It just works. The moment my finger leaves an icon, that app opens. And for that, I'm happy to be carrying around a 1ghz processor...even if it means my new baby is a bit hungrier than some others... I'll gladly feed it however often it needs :)

Extras: I love its FM radio. For my long train ride to work, listening to NPR rocks. Also, it's got a solid metal kickstand, so you can prop the phone up as you enjoy video on its huge screen. Nice touch HTC.

Next Topic: Sprint & 4G

Images courtesy of Me.



 

This is not the "4G" you were looking for...

Posted by Nick

 
 
All this talk of the lost/recovered 4g (4th generation) iPhone has bored the crap out of me. All I care about is the real 4G... The HTC EVO 4G on sale June 4 for $199
 
The iPhone doesn't even deserve to be compared to this much awesome... so I'll let the Evo's stats stand on their own:
  • 4G (WiMax 3-10mb/s)
  • Android (2.1)
  • 8mp camera, with flash
  • 720p video camera
  • Video chat, through the 2nd front facing camera
  • 1ghz Processor
  • 9gb storage (up to 41gb with SD card)
  • 480x800 4.3 screen
  • HDMI out
  • Share it's 4G connection with up to 8 other devices through wifi!
Fuck yeah. 
 
I'll be outside my Sprint store, very early, on June 4th. You should be too. 
 
 
Update: Engadget has some hands on videos. <drool>

Under Construction - iPhone OS

Posted by Nick

 

As I type this, Gizmodo's live coverage of the iPhone OS 4.0 is getting started. I'm exceedingly interested in the new features, updated interface design, and how this new OS will affect the design, reputation, and perception of any other mobile device that is released after it. Another question that (might) be answered is how will this OS better integrate with the iPad hardware. I've seen some remarkable new apps (or updates of existing apps) that do a fantastic job of using the tablets larger resolution/size, but the base OS is more akin to Farley's "Fat guy in a little coat" than a proper implementation of a mobile OS on a 10" screen. Just look at the home screen for chirst sake...

Image001

all that unused space. Even if you fill it up with uncategorized icons, it's still inefficient. Good design always needs white space, but this is just a waste of valuable pixels. The mockup below, shows how the space can be used more efficiently while still maintaining breathing room for all the elements. It's got some great data feeds that don't require you to open an app to get a glance at what's going on in your always connected life.

Image002

It's not perfect, but at least it's the right direction. As it stands, OS 3 is sorely behind it's competitors. Not that Apple has ever aimed to be the most feature laden... focusing instead on making fewer things work well. But their competition, like Android;

Web OS;

Image003


Windows Phone 7;

Image004

are all doing far more and still makes doing everyday tasks easy.

As much as I sometimes hate to admit it, I've loved using my iPhone for the past 2-3 years. Its totally changed the our expectations of what a phone should do for us. It set the bar in more ways than can be counted. When I test out a new phone (Droid, Pre, any HTC phone, etc), the first thing I do is test the responsiveness of the screen and how quickly I can access maps, mail, web, ect. The first phone I've touched, since the iPhone came out, that came anywhere near to "feeling right" was the Nexus One. I expect Pinch-to-Zoom (multi touch in general), accurate screen touches, a somewhat consistent UI between Apps, and solid integration of social media...just to name a few. But now, I expect even more than the iPhone can offer, Multitasking, apps that aren't "approved" by one single inconsistent body, better app organization, higher levels of customization. Thank god for Jailbreaking to get me through these couple of years, it's truly made the iPhone, MY phone with much improved functionality (themes, folders, file access, wifi hotspot, NES emulation, info widgets for the lock screen, video recording on my 3G, and the list goes on).

Unless Apple pulls some amazing shit out of their ass today, they're going to start losing people like me to the "underdogs", Google and Microsoft. For years now, I've said "The iPhone is the best phone you can get for any price", but it's not true anymore. Even at their $99-199 prices, it's not. I already know my next phone, it's the HTC Evo 4G, and there's little Apple can do today to convince me to stick with them. But we'll see ;)

 

UPDATE: Apple announced some pretty impressive stuff. We're looking at: "Multitasking, folders, improved Mail, iBooks, enterprise stuff, preview of Game Center and iAd." Check out the full detailed list.

 

1 page of 1